Items |
Tension-Nut
|
Hydraulic Wrench
|
Hydraulic Bolt-tensioner
|
|
---|---|---|---|---|
Purpose of Use | Tension-Ccontrole | Good | Not recommended | Best |
Torque-controle | Not-good | Best | Not-good | |
Measuring & Testing | Tension-measuring device | Torque-test-bench | Tension-measuring device | |
For Explosion Proof | Perfect | Air-pump needed | Air-pump or or handpump needed | |
Power Supply | Not-needed | Needed | Not-needed by handpump | |
Operation | When tightening the bolts so many as 10 pcs or more of M36 for Example | Not recommended | Best | Not bad |
Bolts so less as 5 pcs or less with M52 for example | Best | Inconvenient | Inconvenient | |
Prepration for tightening | Ony hand torque-wrench anywhere | Electric or pneumatic pump, tool & hoses needed | Same as the left | |
Necessity of Reaction part | Not-needed | Needed | Not-needed | |
Trouble | Trouble free | Risk of oil-leakage | Same as the left | |
For Retightening | Only hand torque-wrench | Electric power-pump, tool & hoses | Same as the left | |
Operation at Ultra-narrow spaces | Best | Not easy | Same as the left | |
Weight for tightening M56 as example | No weight | Total 30kg approx. | Total 25kg approx. | |
Performance | Variation of Bolt tension | Minimum | Very large | Minimum |
Friction between the thread-surfaces & nut seat-surfaces | Zero | Very large | Zero | |
Tightening Performance for bolts in short length like bolt-dia x 3 or less for example | Best | Best | Not recommended | |
Tightening performance for bolts in long length like bolt-dia x 5 or more for example | Good | Good | Best | |
Against Vibration | No loosening | Loosenig happens | Loosenig happens | |
Cost | Price | Cheapest | Expensive | Less expensive |
Maintence cost | Almost zero | Expensive | Expensive |
When the bolt quantity is less than 5 pcs and in large sizes, Tension-Nut is most recommended, in the senses of easy-operation/safety in working/speedy tightening-time & economical cost.